The room is quiet apart from the soft hum of the projector. On the screen behind them are player pathways, squad age curves, development timelines and transfer figures. There is no dramatic soundtrack, no staged intensity. Just two coaches seated opposite one another, coffee between them, speaking plainly. This excerpt is taken from a session at the Arriola Institute, where aspiring managers are invited to understand not only tactics, but the uncomfortable decisions required to build an elite club.

—

Xavi Tamarit: When people speak about building identity, they often speak about style of play, pressing structures, positional distances, recruitment profiles. They speak about the beautiful things. But identity is also built in departures, no?

Iñaki Arriola: Always. Sometimes more in departures than arrivals. A club discovers its honesty when it must choose who leaves. Anybody can speak of values when there is no pain attached. But when a player is popular, when he came through your academy, when supporters know his name from when he was seventeen years old, when staff members have watched him since childhood – then values become expensive. At that moment you either lead the club forward, or you become a museum.

Tamarit: So when supporters say, “This player is one of ours,” what do you say?

Arriola: I say: if he is one of ours, then we should have prepared him for reality. Reality is that elite football has no space for sentiment as a decision-making model. Emotion is important. Humanity is important. Respect is essential. But sentiment cannot decide squad construction. Take Nikola Babovic. Academy graduate. Excellent boy. Good professional. We loaned him to Rapperswil, we created minutes, we created environment, we created patience. But the last eighteen months there was not enough acceleration in his development. This is the phrase young coaches must understand: stability is not always progress. Sometimes a player looks settled, looks comfortable, looks decent each weekend. But internally he has stopped climbing. Then the kindest thing is movement. Young Boys offered €1.6 million. For him, a new challenge. For us, capital to reinvest. For everybody, oxygen.

Tamarit: Many coaches delay that decision because they fear being seen as cold.

Arriola: Yes, because many coaches want to be loved. You cannot lead an elite environment if your need is to be loved. You must prefer to be fair, clear, and consistent. If Babovic stays because I feel guilty, then another younger player loses opportunity. Then the squad wage structure is affected. Then recruitment is delayed. Then standards drop by one percent. Football clubs do not decline only in dramatic moments. They decline through tolerated softness.

Tamarit: You speak often about development as the main killer for young players.

Arriola: Because it is true. Talent is not the main killer. Injuries are not the main killer. Coaches are not even the main killer. The main killer is the inability to make the next step. At eighteen, many players can dominate youth football through athleticism, instinct, enthusiasm. At twenty-one, they must understand tempo, spacing, emotional control, tactical sacrifice, recovery habits, nutrition, communication. If the person does not evolve with the player, then the player stalls. Many clubs say, “He is talented, why has he not made it?” The answer is often simple: because talent stayed the same while the game moved.

Tamarit: And then there is the opposite case. The talented player who leaves quickly.

Arriola: Yes. Michael Janutt. Excellent prospect. Newcastle came. Strong proposal. Big league, big badge, big salary, big story. We would be naïve to pretend such things do not turn heads. Some people still romanticise academy football. They imagine that because a player joined at thirteen, he belongs emotionally forever. This is false. He belongs while interests align. This is not criticism. It is adulthood. Young players have agents, families, ambition, fear, dreams. They compare pathways. They compare leagues. They compare money. Coaches must remove childish illusions from their thinking. Just because they are academy players does not make them loyal. Just because they kiss the badge does not make them permanent. So we accepted €1.5 million and wished him well.

Tamarit: Did that disappoint you personally?

Arriola: No. It educated me again. Managers suffer when they confuse gratitude with ownership. We do not own people. We guide them for a period. If Janutt believes his mountain is elsewhere, then let him climb. My responsibility is Chur.

Tamarit: Then there is the senior case. Different profile. Amedeo Motta.

Arriola: Very different. Thirty-one years old. Strong servant of the club. Good standards. But unhappy with first-team minutes. This is where many young managers make mistakes. They think squad happiness comes from speeches. It does not. It comes from role clarity and minutes distribution. A player can accept being second choice. He can accept tactical rotation. He can accept age. What he cannot accept for long is confusion. If every Monday he believes he may start, and every Saturday he sits, frustration grows in silence. Motta needed to play. We could not promise that honestly. So €350k to Excelsior was correct. Sometimes selling an older player is not about money. It is about emotional hygiene inside the dressing room.

Tamarit: Emotional hygiene?

Arriola: Yes. Resentment is contagious. One disappointed veteran can influence three uncertain younger players. One honest exit can restore clarity to twenty-five people. Managers must understand that the core of the squad shapes the behaviour of the periphery. Standards travel outward. But so does bitterness. That is why your leadership group matters so much. The players with status must still have hunger to develop as people, not only as footballers.

Tamarit: And the case coaches often misunderstand most: the player who performed well on loan, but still leaves. João Correia.

Arriola: Exactly. People say, “He did well, why sell?” Because development and fit are different questions. João progressed well on loan. We were pleased. But when he returned, we evaluated not only his quality, but our direction. What do we need now? What spaces exist? What behaviours are required in our current model? What level are we entering? Sometimes a player returns improved, yet the club has evolved faster than his profile. This is why academies must be five years ahead of the curve. If your academy trains players only for today’s first team, then by the time they arrive, the first team has changed. Youth development is delayed reality. So when Saint-Étienne offered €1.4 million, it was good business and good logic. Moving on young players does not indicate a lack of trust. Sometimes it proves you developed value successfully.

Tamarit: That line is important for young coaches.

Arriola: Very important. Too many coaches speak of youth integration as if it is automatic morality. “Play the kids.” Fine. Which kids? In what context? With what support? With what tactical protection? Replacing whom? At what cost to standards? Integrating youth players every year is hard because elite football punishes charity. The academy player must not be selected because he is young. He must be selected because he can help the collective now, while growing for tomorrow. If not, you damage him twice: first through exposure, then through rejection.

Tamarit:  So identity is not keeping everyone. Identity is choosing correctly?

Arriola: Identity is repeated honest choices. People think culture is slogans on walls. No. Culture is who receives a contract extension. Who gets sold. Who starts after a poor week. Who is forgiven. Who is challenged. Who is trusted with the next level. At Chur, when we were building, some decisions felt harsh. Now that we compete near the top and enter European nights, the same decisions are simply called standards. This is another lesson: when you are small, discipline is judged as severity. When you are successful, the same discipline is praised as vision. So do not wait for applause.

Tamarit: What should aspiring managers remember from these sales?

Arriola: Three things. First: be humane, never sentimental. Second: judge trajectories, not memories. Third: every transfer window either moves your culture forward or drags it backward. A club becomes elite not when it buys expensive players, but when it can make calm, rational decisions under emotional pressure. That is the hard truth. And if you cannot do that, then somebody else will build the future while you protect the past.